The new ParentDish: helping raise kids of all ages

SFIFF Review: Still Life



With only a handful of films to his credit, Sixth Generation Chinese director Jia Zhang-ke has become one of the world's great master filmmakers, and he has the lack of distribution to prove it. Like many other greats from Orson Welles to Hou Hsiao-hsien, he has struggled to get spectators and his movies together at the same place and the same time. His film Still Life won the Golden Lion at the 2006 Venice Film Festival and promptly sat on the shelf. It received a cautious and limited release in New York earlier this year, but since it never turned up on the West Coast, the San Francisco International Film Festival picked it up as an entry in the 51st fest (after failing to secure it for their 50th), and it opens at the end of this week at the Roxie Cinema. It's by far the best film I've seen in this year's fest, and it probably would have been the best of last year too.




With Still Life, Jia reportedly has gone back to indie filmmaking. Something about his big "studio" debut The World (2005) apparently displeased him, even though to my eyes it's his greatest film. No matter: if you were to show Jia's films to a newcomer and ask him to determine which ones were indie and which ones were studio, he'd be hard-pressed to decide. Certainly the sprawling epic Platform (2000) feels like a "big" film, even though it's comprised mainly of small moments. They all have the stamp of a commanding filmmaker regardless of budget. My very first impression of Still Life was that it felt like an epilogue from some other film, a smaller version of something bigger, and that it was the least of his works. But I find that the film won't disappear so easily. The more I think about it, the more I've been able to make certain visual and thematic connections. It's more fully realized and accomplished than it first appears.

Still Life takes place in and around Fengjie, one of the flooded cities that's part of the massive Three Gorges Dam project. The flooding has displaced or will displace anywhere from 1.5 million to 2 million people. (See the documentaries Manufactured Landscapes and Up the Yangtze for more info.) The film opens with a slow pan over passengers riding on a boat on the Yangtze; many seem to be whiling away the time, unconcerned with anything but their daily routines. A miner (Han Sanming) has traveled downriver to find his wife and daughter, neither of whom he has seen in 16 years. And a nurse (Zhao Tao) looks for her husband. Neither of these characters ever meets onscreen, though they share certain visual and story parallels.

They each wander around the bizarre landscape, full of half-demolished buildings and rising floodwaters. Jia is one of the few directors who uses space as a primary character in his films. (Still Life is beautifully, crisply shot on digital video.) In one scene, a man and a woman argue while a large hole gapes in the floor in front of them, and a beautiful view can be seen behind them over a broken wall. This rubble, half-standing, half-fallen, constitutes Jia's view and overall mood. Every shot contains some kind of visual conflict, such as workers pounding away at chunks of wreckage while other workers wearing masks and suits (looking like spacemen) come by spraying some kind of chemical on the grounds. Money is also crucial to the film. Characters use etchings on bills to show images of their hometowns and a magician converts Yuan to euros. (Chow Yun-fat is also seen on TV lighting a cigarette with cash in a clip from A Better Tomorrow.) This world is strikingly different from the amusement park trappings of The World, and its ability to stave off reality in favor of a miniaturized, controlled, happy-faced version.

Making connections across the span of the movie can work like a puzzle, like our miner and nurse gazing across the river from opposite sides, yet unable to see each other. If you can remember an image from 45 minutes earlier, you can connect it to something going on now. But individual scenes work beautifully as well: when the nurse spends several long moments bandaging an injured worker, the scene comes to end when an electrical box behind them suddenly dies in a shower of sparks. In another scene, a structure in the background suddenly takes off like a rocket ship (!) and the final shot rests on a tightrope walker (a tidy little metaphor). Indeed, it's a mistake to look at Jia's films as somber recordings of Chinese history and cultural displacement; he's definitely working through an ironic grin. He's an observer, but he has also taken up residence inside his filmic worlds.

Related Headlines

Reader Comments

(Page 1)

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

New Users

Current Users

CATEGORIES
Awards (824)
Box Office (548)
Casting (3603)
Celebrities and Controversy (1779)
Columns (215)
Contests (201)
Deals (2907)
Distribution (993)
DIY/Filmmaking (1808)
Executive shifts (98)
Exhibition (599)
Fandom (4201)
Home Entertainment (1147)
Images (616)
Lists (344)
Moviefone Feedback (5)
Movie Marketing (2168)
New Releases (1703)
Newsstand (4283)
NSFW (83)
Obits (284)
Oscar Watch (493)
Politics (792)
Polls (23)
Posters (131)
RumorMonger (2108)
Scripts (1474)
Site Announcements (268)
Stars in Rewind (59)
Tech Stuff (407)
Trailers and Clips (479)
BOLDFACE NAMES
James Bond (204)
George Clooney (149)
Daniel Craig (80)
Tom Cruise (229)
Johnny Depp (144)
Peter Jackson (120)
Angelina Jolie (145)
Nicole Kidman (44)
George Lucas (169)
Michael Moore (66)
Brad Pitt (146)
Harry Potter (155)
Steven Spielberg (266)
Quentin Tarantino (141)
FEATURES
12 Days of Cinematicalmas (59)
400 Screens, 400 Blows (103)
After Image (33)
Best/Worst (36)
Bondcast (7)
Box Office Predictions (76)
Celebrities Gone Wild! (23)
Cinematical Indie (3842)
Cinematical Indie Chat (4)
Cinematical Seven (222)
Cinematical's SmartGossip! (49)
Coming Distractions (13)
Critical Thought (347)
DVD Reviews (197)
Eat My Shorts! (16)
Fan Rant (41)
Festival Reports (821)
Film Blog Group Hug (56)
Film Clips (32)
Five Days of Fire (24)
Friday Night Double Feature (23)
From the Editor's Desk (68)
Geek Report (81)
Guilty Pleasures (27)
Hold the 'Fone (425)
Indie Online (3)
Indie Seen (7)
Insert Caption (111)
Interviews (314)
Killer B's on DVD (71)
Monday Morning Poll (47)
Mr. Moviefone (8)
New in Theaters (300)
New on DVD (263)
Northern Exposures (1)
Out of the Past (13)
Podcasts (99)
Retro Cinema (77)
Review Roundup (45)
Scene Stealers (13)
Seven Days of 007 (25)
Speak No Evil by Jeffrey Sebelia (7)
Summer Movies (40)
The Geek Beat (27)
The (Mostly) Indie Film Calendar (32)
The Rocchi Review: Online Film Community Podcast (27)
The Write Stuff (25)
Theatrical Reviews (1529)
Trailer Trash (442)
Trophy Hysteric (32)
Unscripted (33)
Vintage Image of the Day (140)
Waxing Hysterical (42)
GENRES
Action (4624)
Animation (945)
Classics (933)
Comedy (4210)
Comic/Superhero/Geek (2266)
Documentary (1255)
Drama (5429)
Family Films (1079)
Foreign Language (1409)
Games and Game Movies (279)
Gay & Lesbian (219)
Horror (2086)
Independent (2971)
Music & Musicals (849)
Noir (184)
Mystery & Suspense (759)
Religious (93)
Remakes and Sequels (3431)
Romance (1113)
Sci-Fi & Fantasy (2877)
Shorts (257)
Sports (259)
Thrillers (1712)
War (227)
Western (64)
FESTIVALS
Oxford Film Festival (1)
AFI Dallas (45)
Austin (23)
Berlin (89)
Cannes (272)
Chicago (18)
ComicCon (88)
Fantastic Fest (63)
Gen Art (8)
New York (52)
Other Festivals (286)
Philadelphia Film Festival (13)
San Francisco International Film Festival (28)
Seattle (64)
ShoWest (3)
Slamdance (20)
Sundance (596)
SXSW (274)
Telluride (61)
Toronto International Film Festival (340)
Tribeca (258)
Venice Film Festival (10)
WonderCon (1)
Friday Night Double Feature (0)
DISTRIBUTORS
Roadside Attractions (5)
20th Century Fox (569)
Artisan (1)
Disney (538)
Dreamworks (274)
Fine Line (4)
Focus Features (143)
Fox Atomic (16)
Fox Searchlight (167)
HBO Films (31)
IFC (108)
Lionsgate Films (350)
Magnolia (101)
Miramax (64)
MGM (181)
New Line (369)
Newmarket (17)
New Yorker (5)
Picturehouse (9)
Paramount (570)
Paramount Vantage (40)
Paramount Vantage (11)
Paramount Classics (48)
Samuel Goldwyn Films (7)
Sony (479)
Sony Classics (135)
ThinkFilm (105)
United Artists (37)
Universal (628)
Warner Brothers (885)
Warner Independent Pictures (92)
The Weinstein Co. (437)
Wellspring (6)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

  • RSS News Feed
Powered by Blogsmith

Sponsored Links

Most Commented On (60 days)

Recent Comments

Weblogs, Inc. Network

Other Weblogs Inc. Network blogs you might be interested in: